World leaders defy Trump’s self-image of dominance

https://edition.cnn.com/2025/05/31/americas/trump-putin-netanyahu-foreign-policy-intl-latam
Credit: Getty Images

Every head of state believes they have the power to alter the course of history, and Donald Trump is much more self-assured than his more recent predecessors. However, it’s not going as planned for the American leader. Some international leaders are more difficult to intimidate than others, but Trump may use his government authority to attempt to sway courts and institutions like Harvard University.

How are China and Russia dismissing Trump’s threats?

Russian President Vladimir Putin, who is opposing the US attempt to resolve the conflict in Ukraine, continues to disregard and insult him. Trump is now being portrayed by Russian media as the strong talker who never enforces repercussions and constantly blinks.

The president apparently believed that by engaging in a trade battle with leader Xi Jinping, he might reshape China to his own will. He misinterpreted Chinese politics, however. Bowing down to a US president is the one thing a Beijing authoritarian can never do. US officials now express their frustration over China’s failure to fulfil promises intended to defuse the trade dispute. Trump retreated from his trade conflict with the European Union, just as he had with China.

How is Trump’s strongman image failing internationally?

Everyone assumed Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu would agree. After all, he gave the Israeli prime minister almost all he requested during his first term. Trump, however, is discovering that extending the Gaza war is fatal for Netanyahu’s political future, just as Ukraine is for Putin as he attempts to mediate peace in the Middle East. Additionally, Trump’s desire to reach a nuclear agreement with Iran is impeding Israeli preparations to attempt a military takeout of the Islamic Republic’s reactors during a strategic lapse.

In contrast to the more transient, transactional goals of American presidents, powerful leaders are pursuing their interpretations of the national interest that live in a parallel world and on distinct historical and actual timeframes. The majority are resistant to self-serving arguments. 

Last year, Trump boasted for months on the campaign trail that his excellent connection with either Putin or Xi would miraculously resolve complex geopolitical and economic issues between superpowers that would otherwise be intractable.

He is by no means the first American leader to have similar fantasies. The Kremlin tyrant’s soul was reportedly sensed by President George W. Bush as he gazed into his eyes. 

Bush was resolved not to be the world’s policeman when he took office. However, the events of September 11, 2001, forced him to do just that. The United States won the wars he waged in Afghanistan and Iraq, but the peace was gone. Furthermore, his unsuccessful attempt to democratise the Arab world during his second administration never succeeded.

Obama travelled to Egypt to convince Muslims that it was time for “a new beginning” in an effort to atone for the worldwide war on terror. During his early years in office, there was a strong belief that his charm and distinct heritage would be a universal remedy in and of itself.

After removing Trump from the White House, Joe Biden traveled the world to assure people that America was back. However, America—or at least the internationalist post-World War II version of it—was gone once again four years later, in part because of his own unfortunate choice to seek a second term. Trump had returned.

Is Trump’s America First doctrine isolating the US?

Trump’s “America First” populism is predicated on the idea that the US has been exploited for decades despite the fact that it is the most powerful country in the world, thanks to its alliances and influence over global commerce. He is now wasting this heritage and destroying US soft power, or the ability to convince, with his aggression while seeming to be a strongman that everyone must follow.

With its threats of tariffs, threats of US territorial expansion in Canada and Greenland, and dismantling of international humanitarian assistance programs, the first four months of the Trump administration demonstrate that the rest of the world has a role in what occurs. 

Author

Sign up for our Newsletter