Analyzing ‌Trump’s 2024 tariff plan: Does this strategy boost America’s economy?

Analyzing ‌Trump’s 2024 tariff plan Does this strategy boost America’s economy
Credit: Paul Sancya/AP

Download Trump will increase ‌tariffs on foreign goods if he wins the 2024 presidential race. This plan by Trump shows a bold economic strategy. He has a plan to increase tariffs up to 20% on different imports from various nations and 60% increments on goods from China. 

According to Trump, increasing tariffs could boost the US economy, save American jobs and grow tax revenue. He also claimed that these taxes would not affect ‌United States consumers. However, this claim is viewed as misleading by many economists.

Tariff is calculated on the original value of a good. It is a form of domestic tax on different goods. For example, a car costing $50,000 would incur a $5,000 tariff if the rate was 10%. Though the importer pays this tax, it often results in an advanced price for consumers. 

According to 2023 data, US imports reached about $3.1 trillion, representing around 11% of the nation’s GDP. This shows the important role of imports in the nation’s economy. It raises many questions about the effectiveness and impact of Trump’s proposed tariff increases.

Tariffs on imports made $80 billion for the United States government. It is about 2% of total tax revenue. However, figuring out the key players who pay these tariffs is not simple. If the United States decides to increase good prices for consumers, then they end up paying more. If companies decide to absorb the cost, then they suffer losses. Another option is that foreign sellers maintain the US buyers by lowering the prices of their goods. It means they take on the cost. 

Studies from 2017 to 2020 show that most of the burden fell on U.S. consumers. A survey by the University of Chicago in September 2024 found that 98% of economists think tariffs make consumers pay more through higher prices. This shows that while tariffs help the government collect money, they also make it more expensive for American households.

Only consumers can be affected by increasing prices through tariffs. In 2018, Trump put 50% tariffs on washing machines. This policy caused prices to rise by about 12%, adding $86 to each unit. Due to this, US consumers paid an extra $1.5 billion that year for washing machines.

If the same tariffs are put on American goods in the future, then it seems like the economic burden will remain the same. Furthermore, it would also lower income for many US citizens, with the poorest losing around 4% and wealthier households around 2%. Yearly, an average-income household could lose about $1,700. Furthermore, the researcher also predicts that increasing tariffs would become the reason for increased inflation. It poses further risks to the US economy and consumers.  

Donald Trump claims that his tariff strategy would create more jobs for Americans. He said that foreign nations should worry about ‌the lack of job opportunities instead. This idea comes from worries about losing US manufacturing jobs, especially after NAFTA and China joined the WTO.

In 1994, there were almost 17 million manufacturing jobs, and in 2016 this figure was lower and 12 million job opportunities remained. At that time, people blamed trade for this loss. According to experts, one of the other reasons is automation. 

Studies on Trump’s tariffs, like the 25% tax on steel in 2018, showed little positive impact on jobs. For example, jobs in the steel industry went down only slightly from 84,000 to 80,000 by 2020. Also, higher steel prices hurt other manufacturing jobs, like those at Deere & Co. Overall, the idea that tariffs protect American jobs seems misleading and may even hurt jobs in other areas.

A nation’s import and export differences define the trade deficit. Donald Trump often opposed this deficit and said that it hurts the US economy. Back in 206, when the US deficit was  $480 billion, around 2.5% of GDP. In 2020, this deficit rose to $653 billion, despite his tariffs.

Economists also said that Trump’s tariff increments plan raised the dollar’s value. This enhancement makes ‌US goods less competitive. 

Additionally, companies can evade tariffs by relocating production. For example, after the 30% tariffs on Chinese solar panels, manufacturers shifted operations to countries like Malaysia and Vietnam to bypass these costs.At the same time, some people support the idea of tariffs and say it is a good way to enhance the US economy. The Biden administration has followed many of Trump’s tariff policies and added new ones on imports like electric vehicles.

Author

  • NYCFPA Editorial

    The New York Center for Foreign Policy Affairs (NYCFPA) is a policy, research, and educational organization headquartered in New York State with an office in Washington D.C. NYCFPA is an independent, non-profit, non-partisan, institution devoted to conducting in-depth research and analysis on every aspect of American foreign policy and its impact around the world. The organization is funded by individual donors. The organization receives no corporate or government donations.

    View all posts

Recent Posts

Follow Us

Sign up for our Newsletter